I made these postcards for the recent Postcard Swap. All three are watercolor on coldpress watercolor paper. I wanted a theme, but something fun, so I settled on Undersea Halloween.
An angler fish with his pumpkin pal, an angel fish dressed as a clown, and a moray eel vamping it up. The pictures above were taken prior to my adventures below - those are the original paintings.
Now for the horror story portion of our story. I seal almost all my watercolors to protect against moisture and damage. My usual go-to is an archival satin Krylon spray. The morning I was going to mail these I grabbed one of my sprays to give them a quick spritz. I grabbed the matte spray (no big deal, I’ve used it before). Except my spray appears to have gone bad at some point. I was too enthusiastic with my coats and that combined with the bad spray and something about two of the pieces caused this horror:
The angel fish was the only one not badly affected. I cried. Then I googled. I followed every suggestion I could find. I tried a different spray. No effect. I used mineral spirits - miraculously this seemed to fix it! Until the mineral spirits fully dried - and then the two pieces looked the same. I tried a combo of mineral spirits and then a heavy application of Dorland’s wax (another watercolor sealer). It looked like this helped a tiny bit, but not much.
I was heartbroken. Instead of giving up completely, I knew that I had that window with the mineral spirits where the two paintings were restored. Brief but real. So I treated both paintings and then sprinted to my scanner and scanned them into the computer. I adjusted the size, did my best to color match, and then printed them on artist’s quality inkjet paper. I painted new backgrounds, cut out my figures, and glued them in place - adding a glow for the angler fish with some neocolors and gouache.
During my mad scientist portion of this adventure, I made a test piece using the same watercolors and paper. I let it dry and then over-sprayed it with the bad sealant. It frosted similar to the first two pieces when the sealant dried. I immediately treated it with mineral spirits (gently wiped across the postcard’s surface) and then a layer of Dorland’s wax. The test piece was fixed. It’s not as bright as the original, but not noticeably damaged. So timing appears to be a factor. If this happens to you and you can treat the piece quickly enough, you may be able to save it.
I am glad you got the before pictures because they are darling. You picked such a fun theme.
I would have flipped out if the sealant did that. It actually kind of works on the angler fish to look like murky water. Poor moray eel though. Glad you were able to alter and save theart.
I still can’t believe this happened!
Also that you solved the mystery! I totally agree with the title of your post!
Also, what a CUTE theme! well done, watercolor guru
(also, I’m glad you had snapped a photo before the snafu)
Omg I’m so sorry your art got ruined! I’m glad you could at least remake them! I absolutely love these illustrations. Such a cute theme and I’ve never seen it done before! I think the angler fish is my favorite.
I’m glad you found a workaround. I admire your tenacity! I probably would have cried and then tossed them. SOO glad you didn’t because they are just too cute!
@RagingSloth & @Bunny1kenobi - thank you! I was relieved to find a way to still use the art. I have the originals. I’ll repaint the background on the Angler Fish. I may try a few more things on the eel, mostly out of curiosity.
This project would make an awesome entry into the Lettuce Craft Halloween Spooktacular 2026 Challenge! Just check the thread, to see how to submit your awesome creation!